A letter to my prime minister – What will your legacy be?

Prime Minister of Trinidad & Tobago

Prime Minister of Trinidad & Tobago

Dear Kamla,

When you were elected PM, unlike many woman in this country I didn’t feel a sense of achievement for womankind or empowerment in any way. I chose to adopt a wait and see attitude. Since, I believe, that “actions speak louder than words”.

I had expectations of you. I hoped you would erase the memories I had of when you languished under the leadership of Basdeo Panday. What I expected of you, our recently minted SC Prime Minister, was a leader who exuded a strength that allowed you to keep your femininity intact yet remain forceful.

I expected you to be the embodiment of all that is empowerment not only for our women and young girls but also for our men and young boys. I expected you to show us all, that yes you are a woman, and you are capable of successfully running this country in a way that has never been seen before. I expected you to be a role model and to inspire young women here in Trinidad & Tobago and even those regionally, to strive for more, to want to achieve their highest good.

In the almost three years since assuming this hallowed mantle of leader of this sweet twin-island Republic, I call home I continue to wait for your shining moment. I am afraid that the hope so many women saw in the election of this country’s first woman prime minister may be in vain. What many thought would be “an iron fist in a velvet glove” now seems to be a manicured wave in well-coiffed photo-Ops.

My dear, PM when you are not firing errant ministers, you are brushing off as “political mischief” any criticisms directed at your government. Always with the fall back, “I was advised…” you seem incapable of accepting responsibility for anything. I thought the Section 34 Fiasco was the behemoth of all missteps this year. But I was wrong. The worst issue of 2012 for me, has to be the way you handled Dr Wayne Kublalsingh’s hunger strike.

You have been portrayed by many as “mother of the nation” in fact much of your candidacy hinged on your maternal instincts. What kind of example were you setting as a “mother” when you refused to meet with a man demonstrating his right to express his view? What kind of example were you setting when you stood by and endorsed the despicable behaviour of your government ministers as they belittled and attacked Dr Kublalsingh and his family? Or is this perhaps one of those “do as I say, but not as I do” lessons? Seems pretty Orwellian to me.

How is the arrogance you displayed when you ignored Dr Kublalsingh’s call for accountability and transparency by your government any different from the much maligned arrogance of Patrick Manning – our former prime minister? Is it perhaps because you are a woman, so it is not seen as arrogance?

Growe and Montgomery (2000) defined leaders as people “who provide vision and meaning for an institution and embody the ideals toward which the organization strives” (p.1).

You are guilty of the same things you promised to cast out of our political history as you rode your wave to power, instead of vision and good governance, we get miss-speak, misunderstandings and mischief.

Kamla, leaders do not command excellence, they build it. They should be willing to admit mistakes and learn from them…an expectation of leaders both male and female. It may be too late for you to sway me, but it is not too late for you to redeem yourself in the eyes of the public. This is my hope for 2013. You have at least two years left to change the course of your legacy. I wonder…are you up to that task?

All eyes are on you.

Hunger Strike – Day 21

21 days later and Dr Kublalsingh who has been showing end of life symptoms for two days is still on his hunger strike.

I could not bring myself to write anything before now, because I was hoping to write a positive update to the hunger strike and it just never came. Dr Kublalsingh enters Day 21 today, with new conditions to ending his hunger strike. These are:

    1. Point 3 of framework must state clearly no construction on the Debe to Mon Desir section while the committee meets.
    2. Cost benefit, social impact and hydrology reports to be included.
    3. The terms of reference must include provision for oral and written submission made to the committee by residents.


… these “conditions” come on the heels of a meeting the Prime Minister and the Works and Infrastructure Ministry had with members of the Joint Consultative Council (JCC), and other civil society organizations who were seeking to bring some resolution to the impasse.

Coming out of that meeting, the agreement made:

    1. Nidco undertook to make available to the JCC all the relevant documentation in its possession on the project in respect of the Debe to Mon Desir segment of the highway extension.

    2. The JCC undertook to examine all the documentation on the project provided by Nidco and all other relevant documentation and to produce a report within 60 days from yesterday’s date to Nidco for its consideration and its publication thereafter.

    3. Work will continue on sites of the highway released to the contractor.

So in the now 21 days of one man’s courageously brazen act of standing up for what he believes what have I learned about the People’s Pappyshow and their oh so caring leader:

    The PM knows how to flip a man the bird:
    – She never met with Dr Kublalsingh, thus she maintains her stance. (There will be no early elections – this apparently is a very real fear of hers and her cohort)

    – By giving the JCC 60 WORKING days to review the highway documents she has effectively and indirectly given Dr Kublalsingh a death warrant or another reason for detractors to ridicule him. Dr Kublalsingh cannot last 60 more days on a hunger strike, he will die. If he continues with the strike after this “resolution” has been made, he runs the risk of being seen/maligned as a nuisance.

    – Right after giving the JCC 60 working days to review the docs…Kamla said to supporters that “nothing will stop the highway” so thinking people ask yourselves…what pray tell is the point of the JCC “reviewing the documents”?

    – You can support her party but if you speak out against it you will be insulted and denigrated in public.

    The PM knows how to flip the bird at the rest of T&T:

    – Dr Kublalsingh is a warning for what will happen to you if you ever decide to disagree with the People’s Pappyshow. You will be allowed to waste away to skin and bones and be ridiculed for it.

    – Take note thinking people, old people say “when your neighbour’s house is on fire, wet your own.”

Go home bird...you're drunk!

Go home bird…you’re drunk!

Hunger Strike – Day 8

People often say Trinidadians are a bunch of ten-second-Toms…ok the truth is, I say it. News headlines will hold our attention for all of 10 seconds and then we’re on to the next thing. Maybe we’re really a nation suffering with ADHD and they should just put Ritalin in our drinking water. But short of that, what will it take to make this nation sit up and take notice of issues with grave national implications?

An extreme hunger strike apparently.

The issue engaging citizens and the media right now is the extreme hunger strike being undertaken by Dr Wayne Kublalsingh. Today is Day 8. It’s extreme because he has refused food and water as well. This man, who has lost 42 pounds since he started this strike, is now visibly thinner almost skeletal with dry, cracked lips; no doubt evidence of a body thirsting for nourishment.

Persistence.

Bulldozed and arrested. Ridiculed by many. He has been called a madman, a professional protester and an attention seeker, dismissed by the prime minister who mockingly sent an ambulance instead of taking an elevator down to see him; derided by Housing Minister Roodal Moonilal who appeared on a local morning talk show and sneeringly said “he has about 3 to 4 days to go with that.” Dr Kublalsingh has taken a personal stand, which perhaps is one of the strongest in this time of our young nation’s history.

This group, The Highway Re-Route Movement (HRRM) has been fighting albeit quietly to keep their homes and communities in tact since 2005 under the then PNM government. But you should know that talk about this proposed highway has been around since 1981. Dr Eric Williams in his last budget address in January of that year said it would begin in that fiscal year. Since then it has made appearances in many budget speeches by different governments over the years.

Protests escalated when the actual plans for the highway were made public in 2011. While the extreme tactics now being employed by Dr Kublalsingh are just that extreme, would anyone have taken an interest in their plight otherwise? Dr Kublalsingh has achieved that at least: The nation is taking notice whatever stance they’ve chosen to take on the issue.

However, this “issue” has implications for all of us.

As long as you’re paying taxes (which is just about everybody) this affects you. The initial budget for this project was estimated at 9 BILLION dollars, a huge chunk of that goes to the Mon Desir-Debe section of the highway, because there are compensation costs involved.

This is also flood prone area. What is going to happen when it rains and the water has nowhere to go? Taxpayers’ money will be used in clean-up efforts, road repairs and compensation. Is this how you want your money spent?

This part the highway affects the environment. They intend to build the highway through a lagoon. The HRRM’s claim is that this section of the highway project is “destructive and contrary to modern planning approaches to development.” When it comes to adverse effects on the environment, it’s everybody’s problem. There is no negotiation or compromise when it comes to the environment. Or at least in a right thinking world, there shouldn’t be any.

What the proposals are.

“I’m tired of being crushed under the weight of greedy men
who believe in nothing.” – Jax Teller

I fully support and respect Dr Kublalsingh’s stance. It irks me that he has been likened to Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr and even Nelson Mandela. He is none of the above. He is Dr Wayne Kublalsingh, a “social warrior”.

I am not an environmentalist. I like to think of myself as a social warrior. No guns, no ammunition. Just principles and persistence.

And that’s what this hunger strike which is entering its 8th day is really all about. Principles and persistence.

For those of you thinking that the HRRM is against the entire highway project that is incorrect. For those of you who think this is about “land” that is also incorrect. This is about the segment of the highway from Debe – Mon Desir only. This is about community. This is about growing your family and a peaceful way of life. This is about accountability. This is about honesty.


We have produced evidence to show that Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar, Housing Minister Dr Roodal Moonilal and former Works and Infrastructure Minister Warner, from March to June 2012, all made promises to us that the construction would be reviewed.
Dr Kublalsingh and the HRRM have said.

What is disgusting about Roodal Moonilal is that he supported this group when they were in opposition and now in the seat of power and upon realising that they could not bamboozle or confuffle or spin the HRRM away…he is now resorting to derision and sarcasm. Yesterday, “supporters” of the highway extension project came out and one Lorris Supersad has begun his own “hunger farce” in retaliation for Dr Kublalsingh’s strike.

“Right now my mouth dry and I can’t speak to the media. But I proposed to start a hunger strike today from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. because I want a highway.”

Again the HRRM is not “against the highway project” just the segment that is going to destroy their homes and families and the environment. Do not be fooled by paid CEPEP workers who have now come out like cockroaches out of cracks and crannies to cause bacchanal and mock Dr Kublalsingh. This kind of behaviour is what the People’s Pappyshow likes. They are on familiar ground here. And I can already see and hear the disgusting comments and insults.

When will we hold this People’s Pappyshow accountable? When will this government actually follow through with a promise they made? What will it take for the prime minister to be the “mother” she so conveniently turns into when there is some political mileage to be gained and soften her position and end this?

The AG Anand Ramlogan also weighed in and has said the prime minister would be setting a dangerous precedent if she gave in to the demands of Dr Kublalsingh and the Re-Route Movement. I’m confused by this though, because she promised the group that she would look into their concerns and meet with them. That is their demand, that she follow through on the promise SHE made.

Claiming that it is “sub judice” is more bullcrap and they will only fool the ones who allow themselves to be fooled. The prime minister can meet with this group. She can end this. Instead of trying to show how big her lady balls are, she could follow through on the promise she made to these people and end this.

Dr Kublalsingh has taken a stand and has called the government out on its deceit. He has specific demands…not vague airy-fairy wishes that the PM or her cohorts can bullcrap away. This hunger strike is a desperate attempt to get the attention of the PM. Dr Kublalsingh is doing what he believes to be the right thing, no matter the personal cost. And that alone makes this a worthy cause in my eyes. The HRRM is demanding that the prime minister follow through on her promise to look at their concerns and meet with them.

Kamla seems to have forgotten that this pappyshow government of hers is supposed to be the “people’s partnership”. Meeting with them may not change government’s position or change any policies but it will show that the voice of those vulnerable in society, the voice of people fighting for their homes and the right to grow their families in peaceful communities, the voice of people who voted for her, matters and that it can be heard in the face of a mighty government.

If this paPPySHOW government is not careful, Dr Kublalsingh could very well be our “murdered archduke”. All eyes are on you Kamla.

A cry in the wilderness?

Tendering Carnival?

Carnival Tuesday 2011, Spice Band

This is not a fete in here, this is madness…

It seems as though when these ministers get their instruments of appointment it comes with a slap in the face that leaves them stupid and dazed for 5 years.

This PP is a government of ideas and this latest headline grabber joins other Hall of Infamers like the tunnel from Tunapuna to Maracas, Allowing PH Operators the same privilege as H car Owners, Laptops for every secondary school student and the Airport in South. Whatever happened to these ideas?

And why can’t we hear from our PM? A masquerader herself…how does she feel about this latest verbal diarrhea?

Can you privatize the intangible? Can you privatize air? Because trying to privatize this spontaneous combustion of artistic expression, rhythm and music, the heartbeat of a people is what attempting to privatize Trini Carnival will be about.

This newly minted Minister of the Arts and Multiculturalism, Dr Lincoln Douglas seems to have forgotten that Carnival existed before NGC, TUCO, PanTrinbago, before the PP, UNC, and PNM. It existed before The Mighty Sparrow, Shadow and long before Ambassador Machel.

On d road, Carnival Monday 2011, Spice Band

Carnival cannot be privatized.

Carnival may not be profitable for the Government of the day, but the Trinbagonians profit big time. From Bandleaders to Newspapers, hotels to the doubles man by the corner, DJs and even gas stations…the people profit from Carnival.

Maybe you can privatize an event within the festivities…maybe…but not the Carnival. Mr Douglas has to be out of his damn mind if he thinks that this is so. Aunty Verna where are you, when we need you? This one should be sent to St. Ann’s for evaluation.

What Minister Douglas should seek to do is equip the bodies charged with the responsibilities of producing our various Carnival events with trained staff to produce a better product.

But yuh know what I feel, I feel this man was reading papers and saw that Dean A looking to secure the Miss Universe Franchise and he had a “light bulb moment”. But padna before you roll out this idea, think, think some more, stop, think again, speak to stakeholders – bandleaders, heads of the various carnival and Arts related bodies, formulate a game plan aaaaaaand then talk to a PR person BEFORE you make a statement to the public.

I remember, I was helping a cousin with some school projects, proof-reading and editing and she insisted that she pay me. She also thought it was a good way to make some extra money. When I rolled out the idea to a friend, he grilled me worse that the sharks in Shark Tank. I got upset and defensive, but what he did was, show me that having a great idea is one thing, execution and follow-through however, demands a lot of thought and planning. A lesson I will always remember.

Minister Douglas, for your sake, “doh play mas and fraid powder” let this one, like the other stillborns before it, die a natural death.